Feedback Two FindRetro Banners

[Kontrol]

Hey I'm here to ask for feedback on my two latest FindRetro banners as I think they're good but I want to hear others opinions, thanks!

#1:

#2:

Which one do you prefer? Why?
/10!​

 

[broges]

The second one looks awesome! 7/10

 

[Kontrol]

The second one looks awesome! 7/10

It's the first time I've used effects and could you give what I should add on and such? Thanks


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[broges]

It's the first time I've used effects and could you give what I should add on and such? Thanks


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

What do you mean?

 

[Kontrol]

You rated it 7/10, explain to me what you'd like me to add or edit in it. There must be a reason for you to deduct 3 rating points, thus it's best to explain why you deducted those points.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[broges]

You rated it 7/10, explain to me what you'd like me to add or edit in it. There must be a reason for you to deduct 3 rating points, thus it's best to explain why you deducted those points.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Don't over due the logo.

 

[Ruthless]

Good banners bro , Maybe try and use Volter (goldfish) text at the bottom and my favourite is the 1st as the 2nd has a dark effect on it which i really don't like.

Try different effects etc and styles , If you need any basic help then inbox me

 

[Kontrol]

Good banners bro , Maybe try and use Volter (goldfish) text at the bottom and my favourite is the 1st as the 2nd has a dark effect on it which i really don't like.

Try different effects etc and styles , If you need any basic help then inbox me

I like the first one too, with these two I just played around a bit lel. And I personally hate the Volter text as it always comes out blurry for me, or it'll just look too pixelated. That just my opinion, thanks for the feedback!


-Kontrol

 

[Ruthless]

I like the first one too, with these two I just played around a bit lel. And I personally hate the Volter text as it always comes out blurry for me, or it'll just look too pixelated. That just my opinion, thanks for the feedback!


-Kontrol

No Problem , and What do you use for your banners ? I have Photoshop CS6 and it's fine on there.

 

[Kontrol]

No Problem , and What do you use for your banners ? I have Photoshop CS6 and it's fine on there.

Photoshop CS6 and I use Paint.NET to edit things but not for text.


-Kontrol

 

[Ruthless]

Photoshop CS6 and I use Paint.NET to edit things but not for text.


-Kontrol

The Volter text should look fine on PS them.

 

[Kontrol]

It doesn't. Lel


-Kontrol