First Time Using Photoshop

[Cedar]

I usually use GIMP, so I just wanted to try out Photoshop.
If you would like to rate my signature out of ten, I would really appreciate it.

 

[Baevus]

You can do the same with PAINT.NET
but this is good.

 

[Cedar]

Mmm ... I'll try that program out as well, thanks for the feedback!

 

[Kaz]

Looks alright, never been to good with graphics myself so cant really give lots of feedback on shadowing and all that bollox.
Is that the dude in prototype? been a while since i played it so im not sure, just the arm looks like him haha

 

[Logic]

Get rid of the gay "#yolo" in your signature, then it'll look good.

 

[Weasel]

You can do the same with PAINT.NET
but this is good.

This is bullshit. Paint.NET is simple af. GIMP has a lot more features, and I haven't seen anyone make stuff like this with Paint.NET.

It's looks quite good, but I'm not really a fan of this part:

 

[Cedar]

Looks alright, never been to good with graphics myself so cant really give lots of feedback on shadowing and all that bollox.
Is that the dude in prototype? been a while since i played it so im not sure, just the arm looks like him haha

Yeah it is, lol. Thanks for the feedback.

Get rid of the gay "#yolo" in your signature, then it'll look good.

Erm ... that's your opinion ... and I didn't post that, it's in my personal signature, I'm leaving it if you like it or not.

This is bullshit. Paint.NET is simple af. GIMP has a lot more features, and I haven't seen anyone make stuff like this with Paint.NET.

It's looks quite good, but I'm not really a fan of this part:

I guess I can make it blend into the signature, so it isn't sticking out like that.
Thanks for the feedback!

 

[Sysode]

Either way it looks nice. Pretty good for first time on photoshop - if it actually is your 'first' time

 

[Cedar]

It is, GIMP and Photoshop are kind of alike, but with some different tools.

Edit: I thought I would try again with Photoshop and make 3 more signatures.

This one was kind of sloppy, I added to much smudge and the background wasn't connected to the render right, but I guess I can redo it another time.
Rate it !

This one I really liked, I worked on it for about 15 minutes, testing out the different tools on Photoshop.
Rate it !

This one didn't take me to long, it's just simple.
Rate it !

 

[TheButtonMachine]

I usually use GIMP, so I just wanted to try out Photoshop.
If you would like to rate my signature out of ten, I would really appreciate it.

For your first time with Photoshop, it isn't quite bad, but like Holmes said you got to fix that part, it just stands out to much and doesn't fit with the signature; 6/10.

It is, GIMP and Photoshop are kind of alike, but with some different tools.

Edit: I thought I would try again with Photoshop and make 3 more signatures.

This one was kind of sloppy, I added to much smudge and the background wasn't connected to the render right, but I guess I can redo it another time.
Rate it !

This one I really liked, I worked on it for about 15 minutes, testing out the different tools on Photoshop.
Rate it !

This one didn't take me to long, it's just simple.
Rate it !

1. Enough said right there; 4/10.
2. I like how you made the background, but the render's shadowing is kind of bold and messy, also the style of the text doesn't fit and it is out of line; 7/10.
3. It is quite simple indeed, but the stroke around the text doesn't fit in my opinion. 7/10.

 

[Cedar]

For your first time with Photoshop, it isn't quite bad, but like Holmes said you got to fix that part, it just stands out to much and doesn't fit with the signature; 6/10.



1. Enough said right there; 4/10.
2. I like how you made the background, but the render's shadowing is kind of bold and messy, also the style of the text doesn't fit and it is out of line; 7/10.
3. It is quite simple indeed, but the stroke around the text doesn't fit in my opinion. 7/10.

Thanks for the feedback, I'll keep that in mind!